Dear Friends,
On Wednesday, a telemarketer called the church office, offering a new service for pastors called pastors.ai. Our office manager wasn’t impressed, but forwarded the information to me for my amusement. This company offers to “elevate your pastor’s sermon . . . for your church and beyond.”
Here’s how it works. We would forward a few recorded examples of my preaching. The company would use those examples to craft additional resources that would sound like me—live chat, devotional materials, discussion questions, summaries, reels and clips. For an extra fee, pastors.ai would even write a sermon for me. What’s not to like?
This enticing offer came on the same day that a friend forwarded an AI generated political ad. The fake promotional video put words in the mouths of the leading presidential candidates in frighteningly convincing ways. If I hadn’t known better, I might have thought it was real. (Except that one candidate endorsed the other, and we know that would never happen.)
Of course, we are all also familiar with the decade-old Granny Scam—a frantic voice on the phone, claiming, convincingly, that your grandchild needs immediate assistance. It’s sobering that normally-not-gullible people fall for it. But, who could resist the desperate voice of a loved one?
This Sunday, the fourth Sunday of Easter, is often called Good Shepherd Sunday, because in each of the three lectionary years we read a portion of John 10 about Jesus, the Good Shepherd. (Note, Jesus is not good as in “moral,” but good as in “true, proper.”) Part of the chapter imagines Jesus a gate, another casts him as a shepherd, and a third names him “the voice.” Jesus asserts that his is the only trustworthy voice by which his sheep know and trust him.
The other voices of which Jesus warned his 1st century disciples were the voices of faux prophets, self-promoting priests, too-good-to-be-true healers. Fleecing the faithful is, apparently, a perennial pursuit. But Jesus’ followers had it easy. I doubt Jesus himself could have imagined the difficulty we face with discerning a true voice from a generated one, a real need from a manufactured one, a trustworthy source from a scam.
If, as PT Barnum is credited with saying, “There’s a sucker born every minute,” we are being suckered in increasingly dangerous and divisive ways by the nanosecond. (Fun fact, it is believed that PT Barnum never made that comment. Did someone put words in his mouth, as well?)
Please join us Sunday, gathered with sheep who listen for the voice of the True and Proper Shepherd. Here’s the schedule:
Children’s Music, 9:30 a.m.
Godly Play and Godly Play+ at 10 a.m.
Worship at 10 a.m.
Coffee Hour following
A few weeks ago, I was in a meeting with people I didn’t know, gathered around a common task. As we waited for the meeting to start, one of the participants announced, unprompted, “No one is starving in Gaza. I’ve seen the pictures. No one there is hungry. Its all a lie.” No one spoke. We were surprised at the outburst, confused about the impetus, shocked at the lack of sensitivity. When another person opened their mouth to speak, the speaker cut them off, “Don’t start with me. I get all my news from name of news source. They’re the only ones who tell the truth!”
We all pick and choose the voices to which we listen. We place our trust in a variety of individuals and organizations. In many cases, those choices are inconsequential. But in other cases, when lives are at stake, when lies are blatant, those choices can be deadly. How are we to sort among the three voices heard in Sunday’s gospel: the bleating hired hands who flee at the first sign of trouble, the snarling wolves who only snatch and scatter, and the trustworthy shepherd whose life is given for the sheep?
I was not tempted; I am not going to subscribe to pastors.ai. Why would I relinquish my favorite part of this work—words—to an algorithm? Instead, I strive to listen carefully for the voice of my shepherd, and to faithfully convey what I hear. And when I hear or say it wrong, I am, like a sheep, willing to be herded down a better path, to listen again for a trustworthy voice.
See you Sunday,
Pastor JoAnn Post